The heirs of the German publisher Samuel Fischer have demanded that the auction house Sotheby's abandon the sale of Vincent van Gogh's painting ‘Blossoming Chestnut Branches’, valued at approximately $180 million. The family believes that the canvas may have been sold in 1936 because of financial losses linked to persecution by the Nazi regime.
The heirs are represented by the Berlin lawyer Gunnar Schnabel. He has demanded documentary proof that the transaction took place on market terms and that the family would have agreed to the sale regardless of the Nazis' rise to power. Otherwise, in the lawyer's view, the painting should not be put up for auction. Schnabel has also proposed settling the dispute in accordance with the Washington Principles of 1998.
Sotheby's said it had examined the work's ownership history but had so far found no evidence that it was sold under duress. At the same time, the auction house acknowledged the heirs' concerns and said it intended to continue negotiations. The statement did not specify whether the painting would be withdrawn from the sale.
Samuel Fischer acquired ‘Blossoming Chestnut Branches’ in 1909. He was the founder of the publishing house S. Fischer Verlag, whose authors included Thomas Mann, Hermann Hesse and Alfred Döblin. After Fischer's death in 1934, the publishing house was run by his son-in-law, Gottfried Bermann Fischer. After the Nazis came to power, the company's position deteriorated: many of its authors were banned from publishing, and the publishing house itself was split up. Bermann Fischer left Berlin and moved to Vienna.
In 1932 or 1933, the family placed the Van Gogh painting and two works by Paul Cézanne in the safekeeping of the art dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt at the Paul Cassirer gallery in Amsterdam. In 1936, ‘Blossoming Chestnut Branches’ was sold, and it is the circumstances of this transaction that have become the subject of the dispute.

The painting is expected to be among the top lots at Sotheby's sale on 18 November in New York. In total, 12 works by Impressionists, Post-Impressionists and early Fauvists will be offered, including works by Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Paul Cézanne, Claude Monet and Edgar Degas.